New York City Cops…

…ain’t that smart. So sang the Strokes. Don’t know about that, but at least one of our Special Constables definitely ain’t.

I refer of course to the contribution at PMQs today from David TC Davies MP. Aka David “political correctness gone mad” Davies, and, on Twitter, #DavidDaviesgonemad.

“Balal Khan was this week sentenced to just three years in an institution for a violent rape. Will the Minister refer that disgraceful sentence to the Solicitor General, and also investigate the parents and community, to find out how that young man could have such disregard for women’s rights?”

Now…. big intake of breath. Where do I start? Well here’s the Daily Mail report on the case, which was undoubtedly horrible. A 13 year old boy beat, raped and robbed a 20 year old woman. And it’s because he was under 14 at the time that the sentence was so short. Whether the sentence was too short is of course an issue for debate, and a perfectly valid issue to raise in a parliamentary question. But let’s put that to one side for now.

Let’s also leave aside the sheer audacity of TC suddenly presenting himself as a champion of “women’s rights”, which was what made my jaw drop open in disbelief. (A colleague, actually squealed in horror, which I gather could be heard by the TV audience. Though she’d grasped the real import of what he’d said).

And let’s also brush over the silliness of describing rape as a breach of “women’s rights”. Well yes, if you also regard being murdered as a breach of one’s human rights, I suppose. Which it is, but kind of misses the point, doesn’t it?

Let’s focus on what TC was really saying in his question. Which, put crudely, was that the boy raped because he comes from a community – the Muslim community – which doesn’t respect women’s rights. That was what he was saying, wasn’t it?

Now obviously there’s an ongoing debate over Islam and the role of women, and whether the religion is more or less respectful of women than Western cultures, and of course that depends partly on the interpretation of Islam and the form in which it is practised or, even, perverted by extremist elements. And TC will no doubt try to convince his critics that he was trying to engage in this serious, complex debate. But I could point to plenty of examples of Western culture that equally “prove” a correlation between male attitudes towards women and crimes such as rape.

I was going to flag up footballers, their drunken escapades and allegations of rape against them by way of illustration, but that gets into rather tricky territory. So I’ll just use a very simple example.

I’ve mentioned on here before an incident I witnessed when I was about 15. Trivial in a sense, but something that left a lasting impression. (Well it must have – it was thirty years ago!) I was walking the family dog late at night, when a minibus pulled up at the traffic lights near me. The occupants, who had no doubt had a few drinks, had a life-size, naked blow-up doll in the bus with them and were punching it, abusing it, beating it repeatedly around the head… I remember their faces illuminated in the streetlights, contorted in snarls of angry, aggressive pleasure. Yes, it was only a inflatable doll, but they were clearly venting their hatred on it. Their hatred of women.

They were rugby fans. They may well have been Welsh rugby fans. So perhaps TC – a Welsh MP – would like to ask some questions about what in their families, their community led them to have such a lack of respect for women? He’d probably find out they loved their mothers, were fiercely protective of their sisters, wanted to marry a ‘nice’ girl. Not much different to your average Muslim, in fact. But he would never have asked that question of them, would he?

Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: